How to Know If a Motorcycle Accident Settlement Offer Is Fair in Georgia
- 7 sections
- 1 table
- 4 sources listed
The Code this guide cites
An offer is fair when it accounts for every loss Georgia law lets you recover, measured the way a Georgia jury would measure it, discounted only for the risks your case actually has, and attached to a release that does not give up more than it should. Checking that takes four tests: completeness, measure, risk, and terms. Deadlines matter too: some offers lapse, and one kind can shift the other side’s legal fees onto you.
Test one: does the offer account for every category of loss?
Georgia law separates two kinds of damages. “Economic damages” are pecuniary losses, “including, but not limited to, damages for past and future medical expenses; costs of rehabilitation; costs of therapy; loss of wages; loss of income; loss of earning capacity”, the value of unpaid household services the injured person can no longer perform, and funeral or burial expenses. “Noneconomic damages” are everything else, including “physical or emotional pain, discomfort, anxiety, hardship, distress, suffering, inconvenience, physical impairment, mental anguish, disfigurement, loss of enjoyment of life” (O.C.G.A. § 9-10-184(a), as rewritten by Senate Bill 68 in 2025).
A rider checking an offer can list those categories down the left side of a page and ask the insurer to show its number for each:
| Category | What to have in hand |
|---|---|
| Past medical expenses | Itemized bills, and what each provider was paid or is owed |
| Future medical care | The treating doctor's written plan and cost estimate |
| Lost wages to date | Pay records, employer letter, or tax records for self-employment |
| Definite future earnings the injury will cost | Records of scheduled work or pay that will be missed, such as a planned surgery and recovery period |
| Lost earning capacity | Work restrictions from the doctor, and what they cost in pay |
| Motorcycle and gear | Repair estimate or pre-crash value, and who keeps the wreck |
| Pain, impairment, loss of enjoyment | Treatment records, photographs, and the activities that changed |
An offer that names one figure for “all damages” without showing its parts cannot be checked against this list. Asking for the breakdown in writing is the first response. The categories themselves are explained in what damages can be recovered after a Georgia motorcycle accident, and the three kinds of earnings loss in proving lost wages after a Georgia motorcycle accident.
Test two: is it using the measure a Georgia jury would use?
Medical bills after April 21, 2025. For causes of action arising on or after April 21, 2025, when SB 68 took effect, medical expenses are “limited to the reasonable value of medically necessary care, treatment, or services” (§ 51-12-1.1(b)). If the injured person has health insurance, the evidence includes both what was charged and “the amounts actually necessary to satisfy such charges pursuant to the insurance contract”, whether or not the insurance was used (§ 51-12-1.1(c)). For treatment provided under a letter of protection, the letter, itemized charges, and any sale of the account to a third party are discoverable (§ 51-12-1.1(d)). A valuation built only on the billed totals may overstate what a jury will hear for a 2025 or 2026 crash; one built only on what insurance paid may understate it. Both numbers belong on the worksheet. For earlier crashes, prior law governs this point.
Pain and suffering has no formula. Georgia’s statute names the measure of noneconomic damages as “the enlightened conscience of an impartial jury” (§ 9-10-184(b)). A multiplier of medical bills is a negotiating shortcut some people use, not a Georgia rule, and an insurer’s figure built on one can be questioned on that ground. Since SB 68, lawyers may argue a dollar value for noneconomic damages only after the close of evidence, and the argument must be “rationally related to the evidence” (§ 9-10-184(c)). That makes the documentation of how the injury changed daily life the evidence that supports the number. The measure is discussed in how pain and suffering is valued in Georgia motorcycle cases.
Test three: has the offer been discounted for real risks, or invented ones?
A fair offer is lower than full value when real risks exist. The ones Georgia law makes measurable:
- Shared fault. Damages are reduced by the rider’s percentage of fault, and at 50 percent or more the rider recovers nothing (§ 51-12-33(a), (g)). An offer that assumes 20 percent rider fault should say what facts support that figure. See Georgia’s 50 percent comparative fault rule.
- Insurance limits. An offer of the full liability limits can be the most that insurer will ever pay, whatever the injuries are worth. The question then moves to other policies, including the rider’s own underinsured motorist coverage.
- Incomplete treatment. An offer made before the doctor can describe future care values a loss nobody has measured yet. A signed release ends the claim against the people it releases, and if its words reach injuries not yet known, complications found later are covered by it too.
Risks that are not in the record, such as a general claim that “juries don’t like motorcyclists”, deserve a request for the facts behind them.
Test four: what does the release give up?
The release is the price of the offer. Three questions decide whether its terms are fair:
- Who is released? A release of the at-fault driver and that driver’s insurer is ordinary. A release that also covers “all other persons” can reach a second at-fault party, or the rider’s own UM carrier.
- Is it limited or general? When an at-fault driver’s insurer pays its full limits and an underinsured motorist claim remains, Georgia law provides a limited release that protects the UM claim (§ 33-24-41.1). A general release can end it: in Farid v. Gaskell (2022), a family that settled under an agreement having “the effect of a General Release” lost the claim against its own UM carrier. The steps are in Georgia uninsured motorist coverage.
- Who pays the liens? Health insurers, hospitals, and government programs may have claims against the settlement. The net amount after those claims is the number to compare.
Deadlines: when an offer lapses, and when rejecting one costs money
Offers are not open forever. An offer that names a deadline can lapse when it passes, and a lapsed offer has to be made again before it can be accepted.
Before the defendant answers: time-limited offers under § 9-11-67.1. This statute is not limited to offers made before a lawsuit. In the 2024 bill text, it covers a lawyer-prepared offer to settle a motor vehicle injury claim “From the time a cause of action accrues until the filing of an answer by the named defendant”, or, with several defendants, until all have answered or been found in default. The official summary of the 2024 session says Senate Bill 83 makes such offers offers to enter into bilateral contracts, clarifies the time frame for making them and which terms are material, and adds a safe harbor for a recipient who agrees to the material terms and pays the policy limits or the amount demanded, whichever is less.
The bill text read for this page (the House Committee on Rules substitute to SB 83, LC 48 1320S) lists seven terms as “the only material terms”:
- a date to accept, “not less than 30 days from receipt of the offer sent by certified mail or statutory overnight delivery, return receipt requested”;
- the amount of payment;
- the parties to be released;
- whether the release is full or limited, with an itemization of what the claimant will provide to each releasee;
- the claims to be released;
- a date for payment, “not less than 40 days from receipt of the offer”;
- a sworn statement from the recipient about whether all liability and casualty insurance it issued that covers or may cover the claim has been disclosed, due no less than 40 days from receipt, a requirement the offeror may waive.
The same text requires the offer to include medical or other records “sufficient to allow the recipient to evaluate the claim”, to be sent by certified mail or statutory overnight delivery, return receipt requested, to “specifically reference this Code section”, and to give an address and a fax number or email address for acceptance. A recipient accepts by written acceptance of the material terms “in their entirety”, and a written request for “reasonable clarification” is not a counteroffer.
Two cautions go with that list. It is taken from the bill text, so the deadlines should be confirmed against the current Code section before an offer is sent or answered. And the dates differ by source: the official summary says the Act applies to offers made on or after July 1, 2024, while the bill text’s applicability section refers to offers made on or after the date the Act was approved by the Governor; an offer made between the approval date and July 1, 2024 is one for counsel to check. For comparison only, the version in effect before 2024 also required “not less than 30 days” to accept and enough medical records “to allow the recipient to evaluate the claim.”
After suit: offers of settlement under § 9-11-68. Ordinary settlement talks can happen at any time. A formal offer of settlement under this section has its own window: it may be served “more than 30 days after the service of a summons and complaint on a party but not less than 30 days (or 20 days if it is a counteroffer) before trial” (§ 9-11-68(a)). It stays open for 30 days unless withdrawn in writing, and an offer neither accepted nor withdrawn in that time is “deemed rejected.” The consequences run both ways:
- If the defendant’s offer is rejected and “the final judgment obtained by the plaintiff is less than 75 percent of such offer”, or the judgment is one of no liability, the defendant may recover its reasonable attorney’s fees and litigation expenses from the date of rejection through judgment (§ 9-11-68(b)(1)).
- If the plaintiff’s offer is rejected and the plaintiff recovers more than 125 percent of it, the plaintiff may recover its fees and expenses on the same terms (§ 9-11-68(b)(2)).
For example, imagine a defendant serves a $100,000 offer under § 9-11-68, the rider rejects it, and the jury’s award, after any fault reduction, comes to $70,000. That is less than 75 percent of the offer, so the defendant can seek its fees and expenses from the rejection date forward. An offer of this kind is one to have a lawyer review before its 30 days run.
Before you answer an offer
- Ask for the insurer’s breakdown by category, in writing.
- Put both medical numbers on your worksheet: charged, and paid or owed.
- Check the stated fault percentage against the evidence.
- Find every policy that could pay, including your own UM coverage.
- Read the release: who is released, limited or general, and who pays liens.
- Write down the offer’s deadline, and whether it is a § 9-11-67.1 or § 9-11-68 offer.
Sources
- O.C.G.A. §§ 9-10-184 and 51-12-1.1 as enacted by Senate Bill 68 (2025), as passed, §§ 1, 7, 9.
- O.C.G.A. § 9-11-67.1: the version in effect before the 2024 revision, as published in March 2024, quoted for comparison only; Senate Bill 83 (2024), House Committee on Rules substitute, LC 48 1320S; and the summary of Act 415 (SB 83) in the Georgia General Assembly’s summary of general statutes enacted at the 2024 session.
- O.C.G.A. § 9-11-68 (text as republished by rulesofcivilprocedure.com, read October 25, 2026; no amendment listed in the 2022 to 2026 summaries of general statutes enacted); §§ 33-24-41.1, 51-12-33.
- Farid v. Gaskell, No. A22A0899 (Ga. Ct. App. Nov. 1, 2022)
This page describes Georgia law as of October 2026 for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.